Dedicated to providing information for learning assistance professionals.
Percolation-a productive form of procrastination
By Kyle Cushman, Vermont College of Union Institute and University
You've heard the stories from students, or maybe even done it yourself. It's ten o'clock at night and you are facing a deadline on an important writing assignment. You should be sitting at your computer in fact you should have sat down three hours ago. But suddenly it's imperative that you reorganize the kitchen cupboards. After all, the pots and pans simply don't fit in that drawer-the handles are always catching when you open it. You can't find the spices in the spice cupboard anymore because it is so crowded and littered with onion and garlic skins. And you must clean up the sticky spot left by the honey jar. You just can't bear this chaos for one more day!
What I have just described is a scene, which typically gets labeled "procrastination" by most students, most teachers and many learning support personnel. But what if, for some kinds of writers, this type of procrastination is an essential part of their writing process? What if, while wiping up spilled flour on the bottom shelf, this type of learner is accomplishing valuable writing work?
Indeed, there are many writers who must process their topic in their minds before actually sitting down to do any physical writing, even before doing pre-writing activities like brainstorming. Indeed, while driving, taking a shower, hiking, or talking with a friend, these writers mull over ideas in their minds, investigate patterns and connections, and turn the topic around and around. They are looking for an angle, searching for a focal point, for a way to begin.
I am normally a very productive person who pursues tasks in an efficient, timely manner. But in my workday life, I have noticed that when I have a writing assignment due, I suddenly get nothing done for a period of time. It's as if I am floating adrift in an ocean current. I know desperately that I need to swim, but I can't. This period of time can last for a half an hour or a half a day. Then suddenly I break through the surface of the water--I am ready to write. And I do.
At our learning support office we call this process percolation, rather
than procrastination. The problem is that this part of the writing process
often goes unnoticed and is not validated by the student/writer or by
anyone else. What is noticed instead is that the deadline is looming
and the paper is not getting written and the student is thus doing a
bad thing-procrastinating. The student then falls into the trap of admonishing
him/herself for laziness and avoidance of writing. This increases stress,
anxiety and feelings of self-doubt, which can turn the valid process
of percolation into true procrastination. In other words, the student
may think, "Why bother starting now since I've wasted so much time
and I'm such a loser?"
Learning center coaches can help
It is important for students to learn that the process of percolation is a productive part of the writing process. If percolation is part of their learning style, they can achieve greater success by honoring this need and valuing the fact that they work through ideas while cleaning out their dorm room closet. Some writers need to do a lot of percolating and when they finally sit down to write, the paper simply pours out of them in practically finished form. Other's will percolate a little, write a little, and then percolate some more. And some writers percolate very little, needing to actually see words on the page to get a handle on their ideas. Learning center coaches, through exploring instances of "procrastination" with students, can help students to determine whether they might instead be percolating and then help them to develop a conscious awareness of this part of their process.
To help a student determine if he/she is percolating or procrastinating, encourage the student to keep a record for a period of time of when, how and why he or she engages in other activities when he/she should be doing schoolwork. How quickly did writing occur after the distracting activity? Was the writing easier as the result of taking time to do something else? Have students write down their most common procrastination activities and evaluate which activities helped them to percolate ideas and recharge their batteries, and which activities were simply ways to avoid getting started.
Once a student is aware of this need to percolate, he or she can consciously build time for it into their writing schedule (thus avoiding missed deadlines). In honoring this step, students can avoid the shame and self-judgment that comes around the notion that they are procrastinating.
There are, of course, always some cases where procrastination is unproductive
and can endanger a student's ability to succeed. These cases of intentional
avoidance of difficult tasks can be helped with the following strategies.
What to do when procrastination is not productive:
|Home:: Past Articles :: Conferences :: Citation Information :: Feedback :: About the Authors :: Subscription Information|